Rollins was down 19 late in the second half and came screaming back to make it a four-point game in the final seconds, but the comeback ran out of time as the Tars fell to Warner 100-95 in the home opener Wednesday.
The second-seeded Tars will host the third-seeded Nova Southeastern Sharks in semifinal action.
The freshman keeper earns a spot on the Second Team.
The Tars will play Barry and Palm Beach Atlantic at home this week
O'Brien is the second Tar to be named Player of the Year and third to be named Offensive Player of the Year.
Kathryn O'Brien, Meghan Mosley, Bailey Tran, Gianna Merigliano, and Elena Beasley all earn recognition.