Rollins missed a pair of penalty kicks, and fell to Barry 1-0 in SSC play.
Two first half goals from Florida Southern hand the Tars their first loss of 2018.
The No. 14 Tars will face off against rival No. 18 Florida Southern and Barry in their opening conference games.
Rollins jumped from No. 21 to No. 14, as they now prepare for a battle with No. 18 Florida Southern.
Rollins tallied five goals, including two from SSC leader Stefan Avram
Rollins moves to 5-0-0 on the 2018 season